Consultant Opinion Sheet

JOURNAL OF ENDOUROLOGY
C/O Division of Urology
Long Island Jewish Medical Center
New Hyde Park, NY 11042
    Reviewer Information

    * Name:

    * Email:

    A.

    Manuscript Information

    * Title:

    * Manuscript Number:

    Priority rating for publication with number 1 having the highest priority.
    1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

    B.

    Is this significant?

    Yes No

    New?

    Yes No

    Worth publishing?

    Yes No

    C.

    Recommendation
      Accept "As Is"
      Accept with Minor Revision
      Major Revision Required
      Reject

    Scientific Quality

      Superior
      Good
      Fair
      Poor

    Presentation

      Superior
      Good
      Fair
      Poor
    D.

    Comments for Editor: In the space below, please provide a brief and compelling Argument supporting (a) your recommendations and (b) your rating of scientific quality and presentation. These comments are for the guidance of the Editor and will NOT be sent to authors.

    NOTE: This section may be omitted if the comments to the author on page 2 are self-explanatory. If major revisions are required and you wish to re-review the manuscript before acceptance, please indicate so here



    THE JOURNAL OF ENDOUROLOGY SUGGESTIONS FOR TRANSMITTAL TO AUTHOR:
     Please do NOT comment here whether or not the manuscript should be accepted